Why is Emergency Glucose Packaging so Hard to Open?
In its more severe manifestations, hypoglycemia can trigger bizarre or violent behavior, impair driving enough to land PWDs (people with diabetes) in jail, and increase the risk of injury or even result in death.
Luckily, reversing a low or dropping blood sugar level is a simple matter of consuming some fast-acting sugar, and all manner of emergency glucose products have been created to help us. There are glucose tablets, glucose powders, glucose gels, and glucose liquids.
But while a lot of thought has gone into the products themselves, very little thought â€” it seems â€” has gone into how these life-saving emergency products are packaged.
The packaging problem
Itâ€™s also ironic that while these emergency glucose products are made to help a person experiencing the confusion and â€œbrain fogâ€ of a dangerously low blood sugar, the packaging is typically quite complex to open â€” even for a person whose brain is at full capacity.
Glucose tabs, for example, come packaged in a plastic vial or container that is tightly sealed with form-fitting plastic, which can take many long minutes to break and unravel. Glucose liquids typically have squeeze tops that require strength and dexterity to pop. And the plastic pouches that contain glucose gel are, by definition, difficult to rip open.
The problem here isnâ€™t just the â€œApple factorâ€ â€” the idea of making packaging beautiful and elegant for its own sake. Rather, when it comes to emergency glucose, the functional issue MUST take precedence: It needs to be easy to open in an emergency. Because when people experience hypoglycemia, their mental acuity is severely degraded, and their physical dexterity is impaired.
The result is acting like a bumbling fool because your brain and hands arenâ€™t working right. So why in the world isnâ€™t the packaging for these emergency products designed to be simpler to access?
This is a question that PWDs have been asking publicly for nearly a decade.
We ask the manufacturers
DiabetesMine reached out to all the major manufacturers of glucose products and asked exactly that question, and the silence was nearly deafening. Only Annmarie Ramos, Trividia Healthâ€™s Senior Manager of Product Marketing, responded. Never heard of Trividia? Founded in 1985, they are the largest manufacturer of store- branded diabetes products in the U.S.
Its portfolio includes blood glucose meters and strips, sharps, diabetic skincare products, and glucose tablets, gels, and liquids â€” all under the brand name TRUEplus.
Its glucose tablets come in large plastic jars, smaller travel tubes, and pouches of four â€œsoft tabs.â€ Its gel is packaged in a soft envelope squeeze pouch, and its liquids in the Dex4-style mini bottle. All have the typical tight plastic seals previously described.
Ramos says her companyâ€™s products â€œhave packaging that is easy to open,â€ but she provided no details on whether this has been tested by PWDs in any real-life scenarios.
The companyâ€™s main message was this: â€œWe suggest that the product be opened after purchase so it is ready to be used in emergencies.â€
On the larger bottles, she says â€œthe perforated safety seal should be removed after purchase. Same for our 10-count tablet tubes, which have a tab on the cap for ease in popping off to open.â€
She also insists that â€œfor our Glucose shot bottles, the large caps are easy to twist off.â€
Getting harder to open?
I personally have been living with type 1 diabetes since 2004 and have found that â€œliquid shotâ€ products from Dex4 and others have gotten more difficult to open over the years â€” presumably because the companies think this is a safety issue. At first, it was just a matter of applying a little extra â€œelbow grease.â€ But by late 2019, I found I had to use a pair of pliers to break open the twist cap. Then the day came in early 2020 that, even with pliers, and not even hypoglycemic, I couldnâ€™t get the darn thing open. In fact, one effort to pre- open a bottle triggered a hypo.
Also, if you choose to pre-open the liquid vials, as Ramos recommends, you, of course, increase the risk of leakage.
This might be a reason to switch to gel pouch glucose. Ramos tells us that Trividiaâ€™s TRUEplus pouches have â€œa notch at the top of the pouch for ease in opening.â€ While itâ€™s true that most glucose pouches are easier to open with hands or teeth than the bottles, that doesnâ€™t mean the true needs of PWDs were considered in the development of the productâ€™s packaging. Thereâ€™s still a big risk of leakage, and theyâ€™re not always ideal to carry. Read on.
A diabetes designer weighs in
We checked in with diabetes designer Sara Krugman of Healthmade Design â€” who worked on Tidepoolâ€™s diabetes data interface and also the future iLet Bionic Pancreas system â€” to see if she knew anything about the world of glucose packaging.
Krugman says, â€œI only know this kind of production vaguely, but I do know there are quality tests â€” probably a machine dropping something on the goo packet to see when and how hard the impact needs to be to break it.â€
Well, I personally have had any number of these packets rupture in my pocket, which is an unnaturally gross feeling sticking your hand into your own pocket and encountering a sea of slime. And donâ€™t get me started on the embarrassing stain, smell, and stickinessâ€¦ not to mention that when your gel packet ruptures, you no longer have the glucose you need in an emergency to keep from shouting at your spouse, staying out of jail, avoiding an injury, or dropping dead.
I also had a first-time negative experience with a gel pouch recently. It cut me. I was wearing a pair of slacks with thin-lined pockets, and the sharp edges of the pouch actually cut several long, painful lacerations in my skin, right through the cloth!
That highlights the other side of the coin with emergency glucose packaging thatâ€™s going unaddressed: Not only does it need to be easily opened by fools, but it also needs to be carried with ease, 24/7/365, so that we have it at the ready when we need it.
A patientâ€™s glucose wish list
Long-time diabetes blogger Bernard Farrell has been an outspoken critic of glucose product packaging. He tells DiabetesMine that this came up again recently, â€œas I struggled to unwrap a vial of glucose tabs.â€
He dreams of something â€œmore like a circular jelly belly that also had 4 to 5 grams of very fast-acting carbs per serving. Then you could use a similar cylinder as the current one for a pack of 10 to 12 and a larger refill container to replenish those packs.â€
â€œIdeally,â€ says Farrell, we need â€œsomething that works to dispense one gel cap at a time with a button push, so you donâ€™t risk losing the lid, and donâ€™t drop them when you try to get a few out of a container.â€
He also points out the need to have dispensers cheap enough that PWDs can have multiples around. â€œIf those are inexpensive enough, then I can keep one in each coat pocket, and each car. Also, in my gym bag, and my office drawer.â€
Read more on: aging