Scientists Quash Claims About Single 'Depression Genes'

Curated by Claudia Shannon / Research Scientist / ishonest

Researchers at the University of Colorado Boulder (CU Boulder) reviewed hundreds of investigations that, over the last 25 years, had singled out “candidate genes” for depression. They found that 18 such genes had featured at least 10 times in previous studies.

Then, using data from hundreds of thousands of people, they showed that the influence the 18 candidate genes had on depression was no stronger than that of genes they could pick out at random.

ishonest No.401 - Dark Circles

No.401 - Dark Circles

In an American Journal of Psychiatry paper, the team concludes that early theories about “depression candidate genes” are wrong and that studies identifying them have likely done no more than produce “false positives.”

The findings dispel the notion that people will soon be able to take a test that identifies a few genes for depression, and then it is just a matter of drug developers producing new medications that target them.

‘Candidate-gene hypotheses’ and depression

Meanwhile, others in fields including psychology, he adds, have continued to pursue the idea of “depression genes” and seemed to find evidence to support it.

For example, one of the 18 “historic candidate depression genes” is SLC6A4, which codes for a protein that has to do with transport and recycling of serotonin in the brain.

Are You Experiencing Skin Dryness And Irritation As The Seasons Change?

Learn more

About 20 years ago, researchers had suggested that having a particular, shorter variant of SLC6A4 could put people at greater risk for depression, especially if they had experienced trauma during childhood.

Dr. Keller explains that the evidence linking candidate genes to depression often came from studies in which the sample sizes were too small. He likens it to the Hans Christian Andersen story of the “emperor’s new clothes.”

“There’s just nothing there,” he adds, “I hope this is the final nail in the coffin for those kind[s] of studies.”

Feeling sad, lonely, or down is part of everyday life, particularly during times of high stress or loss. Depression, however, is a psychiatric illness in which these symptoms, and others, are severe and persistent.

ishonest No.231 - Pigmentation & Blemishes

No.231 - Pigmentation & Blemishes

Depression has many forms and, while each has its own pattern of symptoms, there are also some similarities.

Major depression is the most common type of depression. The symptoms can be so severe that it stops people being able to work, study, and interact socially.

In the United States, depression is the main cause of disability in those aged 15–44 years. In 2016, around 16.1 million adults in the U.S. had had at least one episode of major depression in the previous 12 months.

Data came from very large samples

Dr. Keller and his team analyzed “data from large population-based and case- control samples” that ranged from no less than 60,000 to in excess of 400,000 individuals and totaled more than 620,000. The data came from sources such as 23andMe, UK Biobank, and the Psychiatric Genomics Consortium.

1 Natural Way to Get Rid of Pimples as Fast as Possible

Learn more

The researchers looked for links between any of the 18 depression candidate genes and depression and also with depression in combination with environmental factors, such as “sexual or physical abuse during childhood, socioeconomic adversity.”

However, they write that “no clear evidence was found for any candidate gene,” neither with depression or with depression associated with environmental factors.”

Dr. Keller and his team emphasize that they are not suggesting that researchers should stop looking for links between genes and depression.

What they are saying is that the relationship between genes and depression is not as straightforward as many earlier studies may have claimed.

ishonest No.111 - Purge Impurities

No.111 - Purge Impurities

Research on the risks of diseases such as Alzheimer’s and cancer can reveal strong links with individual gene variants, and tests for those are medically useful for screening and choosing treatment options.

However, it is more likely that predictions of genetic risk for depression will involve “polygenetic scores” that take into account the effect of very large numbers of genes.

“We are not saying that depression is not heritable at all. It is. What we are saying is that depression is influenced by many, many variants, and individually each of those has a minuscule effect.”

Matthew C. Keller Ph.D.

Read more on: claims, depression

What we do

We make skincare treatments and customize them for your skin-related problems, genetics, lifestyle, and environment.

How you benefit

You get total control over your skincare and the choice to change your skin. An impossible has just become possible.

How Custom Beauty Works

Desktop Mobile Graphic
Take the Quiz

Tell us about your skin, general health, lifestyle, environment, and all your skin goals. The quiz takes 4-8 minutes.

Outline of microscope
Create Your Treatment

Our algorithm creates a unique routine with a few customized products. The algorithm uses 50+ years of skincare research.

Outlines of Packaging
Divide and Rule

Every product is designed for one problem. Apply the product when the problem appears. Much like you treat flu or headache.

Product Values

A family sharing common values functions effortlessly and effectively. So do our products. All our products share these values.

Outline of bulb

Typical skincare routines confuse your skin with 20-50 ingredients. Our custom routines contain 1-8 ingredients, sending clear signals to your body to use the ingredients and recover faster.

Outline of Green Leaf

Our skin can use only active ingredients, also called actives. Most products contain up to 10% actives, whereas our products contain at least 90% actives. You get better value. Your skin avoids junk food.

Get Started

Never Used Before

Take the quiz below and discover a customized treatment for your unique skin-related problems, lifestyle, and environment.

Know Your Treatment

Every treatment has a unique 3-digit ID. You can find the ID on the product label. Search the ID on top right corner or click below.

Targeted Solutions

If a particular skin problem is bothering you, browse our products for your specific problem. You can customize your routine later.