People on Surviving The Retinoid Uglies

Curated by Claudia Shannon / Research Scientist / ishonest

But a little-known side effect of retinoid is something colloquially known on internet message boards and the beauty world as the retinoid uglies. Known as a skin-care coming of age phase, it's an adjustment period (the timing is different for everyone) when your skin purges, often resulting in excessively red skin and peeling. Much like puberty, the retinoid uglies feel different for everyone. The experience can get so bad that there are even Reddit support groups. ishonest talked to seven people who went through the uglies about what it was like, and their advice for getting through it.

Iva: It was a defining experience

How gnarly was it? I've been a regular user of Retin-A since 2015. I'm afraid this is my whole personality now. I'm like the dad from My Big Fat Greek Wedding who spritzes Windex on everything, except only with my gnarled tube of Retin-A.

My retinoid uglies were such a defining experience that I wrote a whole essay about it. If you use a very strong retinoid on severe cystic acne, the pus- filled zits start dying and they leave behind these little hollowed-out corpses, scattered husks of pimples, dead skin, and dry flakes. Once the zits had gone, my face went from resembling a sea creature shedding its carapace to one generating its own bioluminescence.

Evelyn: Stick with it

How gnarly was it? I've been using retinol on and off since high school. My first experience was Neutrogena Healthy Skin Anti-Wrinkle Cream, which gave me great bang for the buck and no uglies. I upgraded to Avibon (a.k.a. A313) after visiting France. It made my skin itch and left me with red flaky patches at first, but it was gone after a week. My ugliest retinol uglies were from prescription 0.05 percent tretinoin by Actavis. It was terrible but then glorious.

For two weeks, my skin was red, dry, and weirdly furry. I felt like I was my eighth-grade self back on Accutane. To combat the dryness, I switched from using it every day to twice a week. But afterward, I had this newborn-baby skin that I couldn't stop stroking. My pores were smaller and the blackheads on my nose had disappeared.

Her advice: Drop application down to two to three times a week. Drink lots of water. Apply a gentle natural moisturizer multiple times a day. And stick with it. The best is yet to come, unless you're having an allergic reaction. Then you should stop.

Maham: Take selfies

How gnarly was it? I was one of those poor unlucky preteens who begun battling with acne at 12. A dermatologist finally put me on my first heavy course of Accutane at 19. In between, I've used tretinoin, adapalene, and Differin for spot treatments and as a preventative thin layer all over the face.

Retinoid gives me the kind of smooth skin I thought was only a myth. But a single night of using it can inflame my entire face with tiny bumps that feel like burns. My skin sheds in actual, tangible layers that I can peel off myself. My face throbs for hours after I put something on. Ultimately, I'm not strong enough to handle tretinoin with active acne. The only thing that helped was slathering copious amounts of Laneige Water Sleeping Mask every night.

Her advice: Take pictures! Don't look at them but take them. I wish I had. They're wonderful to look at years later when you're losing your mind over a single zit. They can serve as a reminder of how far you've come! Moisturize, do spot treatments, use Vaseline, don't touch your face. Binge watch a lot of TV because by the time you're done with the new season of Schitt's Creek, the purging will be over.

Charlotte: Don't forget about sunscreen

How gnarly was it? Not terrible! I use a Retin-A cream (tretinoin) prescribed by my dermatologist. I had a boss with great skin who once told me it was the best thing I could do to prevent wrinkles, so even when I was still getting zits, I was like, Hey, at least this'll benefit me out in ten years. Now I'm in my mid-30s and my skin is pretty smooth and clear, with small pores and no scars.

Stay in touch.

Her advice: I got really religious about sunscreen when I started using Retin- A because I read about how it thins your skin and I envisioned my face looking like a potato chip.

Jane: Start gradually

How gnarly was it? My derm put me on Retin-A Micro for acne back in my early 30s. I used it for about ten years. My retinol uglies came in the form of lots of flaking and redness, but it sure helped clear up those breakouts! I can't remember how long the uglies lasted, but my dermatologist had me take the usage down to every few days. She ultimately switched me over to a creamier, more moisturizing version: Retin-A Cream .01 percent.

Her advice: Start slow and see how your skin handles it. Try it every few nights, work your way up to every other night, and so on. (Don't use it during the day, as it makes skin super-sensitive to sun exposure! And even if you only use it at night, you still need to up the SPF during the day!) Also, don't slather it on heavily. More isn't necessarily wiser.

Meg: Try it over moisturizer

How gnarly was it? I started using using the prescription retinoid Atralin at 0.05 percent when I was 12 for acne. I remember it making my skin a little dry and slightly flaky, but it only lasted a few week. Plus, my skin was clear, so that is all I cared about.

My dermatologist then upped my dosage to a generic form of tretinoin at 0.1 percent when my skin broke out freshman year of college. The high concentration and my overuse led to chemical burns on my chin after a week. My skin healed after about a week of proper use, icing of the area, and a simple moisturizer.

This past year, I discontinued my use of prescription retinoids all together and switched to The Ordinary's Granactive Retinoid 2% Emulsion, and I haven't had any irritation. To be safe, I initially put it over my moisturizer when I first switched. I've been using it for two months and only seen positive results.

Her advice: Keep your skin care simple if using it, listen to your dermatologist, and try the trick of using it over your moisturizer when you first start.

Diana: Moisturize, moisturize, moisturize

How gnarly was it? I've been using prescription tretinoin 0.025 percent, the generic one, for about three years. Since I have really dense, oily skin, I didn't experience the terrible peeling that came along with prolonged use. I had some mild peeling around my nose and cheeks but that ended after the first month. You had to look really closely at my face in order to see it at its worst. It helps control my oil production, which was especially bad in warm weather. I need Retin-A psycho, not micro.

Following the light redness and peeling, my skin was much smoother and I saw my acne scars fade. I stopped getting blackheads and whiteheads across my forehead and nose. I didn't see much in fine line reduction but I also never really had them.

Her advice: Moisturize! There's really nothing you can do besides use a thicker, heavier cream than normal.

7 Retinols and Retinoids to Try

This is one of the few retinoids available without a prescription. Differin is adapalene, a third-generation retinoid that studies show is especially effective against acne. The gentlest retinoid on our list, this is the lightest option offered by the Ordinary, making it ideal for anyone who's afraid of going though the uglies. Its formulation relies on a retinoic acid ester. RoC is of the first drugstore brands to use stabilized retinols and is a longtime favorite on Amazon. A313 is a low-percentage retinol (vitamin A) cream French drugstore staple. The texture is a bit like sticky Vaseline, but a little goes a long way, as redditors will tell you.

This one was created by L.A. facialist Shani Darden and is beloved by celebrities like Kim Kardashian, Chrissy Teigen, and Kelly Rowland. It contains 2.2 percent encapsulated retinol, with a rich moisturizing base to avoid irritation. It's also free of oil, fragrance, and silicones.

If you want to try retinoid (the strongest type, which requires a prescription) but don't want to go to a dermatologist, there's Curology. Its website asks you to answer a few questions and snap some selfies, then connects you with a licensed medical professional who develops a custom retinoid prescription cream that you get in the mail. The creams contain a mixture of ingredients, such as tretinoin, niacinamide, and azelaic acid. As a trial, the first month is generally free; prices can range from $25 to $60 afterward.

Much like the Ordinary product above, this also relies on a retinoic acid ester, which is almost as strong as prescription-level. Dermatologist Dr. Shereene Idriss often recommends this one as it causes limited irritation.

Read more on: retinol

Leave a comment

All comments are moderated before being published